Legal Review and Approval: Ensuring Compliance Every Step
Legal Review & Approval: Ensuring Compliance Every Step
In the ever-evolving world of political campaigns, advocacy efforts, and petition drives, one overlooked detail can trigger major consequences. Whether it’s a missing disclaimer, an unverifiable claim in a digital ad, or improperly reported donations, the risks of non-compliance are real—and growing. In this high-stakes environment, legal review and approval is not a box to check. It’s your insurance policy, your campaign’s first line of defense, and often, the difference between success and public scrutiny.
This guide is for campaign managers, nonprofit leaders, advocacy strategists, petition consultants, and field vendors who need to understand how legal review fits into every step of a campaign’s lifecycle. We’ll walk you through the full process, identify common pitfalls, and show you how to implement a streamlined review strategy that keeps your efforts both effective and compliant.
What Is Legal Review and Approval?
At its core, legal review and approval refers to the process of evaluating all campaign and advocacy materials, actions, and strategies to ensure they align with local, state, and federal laws. This applies to mailers, websites, petitions, texts, finance documents, volunteer communications—everything that has public or operational exposure.
There’s a big difference between having your communications director “gut-check” a message versus obtaining formal legal sign-off. The former is informal and subjective; the latter is a structured, documented review performed by professionals who understand election law, advertising standards, and compliance requirements.
When is it required? The answer: practically at every stage—before launch, during creative, prior to execution, and after filing reports. Real-life campaigns have been fined, sued, or disqualified for skipping this process.
Every Stage Requires Legal Eyes
To run a legally sound operation, legal review must be integrated across the entire campaign workflow:
1. Pre-Campaign Planning
Start with legality in mind. Your ballot language, entity registration (PAC vs 501(c)(4)), fundraising channels, and state-by-state strategy all need a legal foundation.
2. Creative and Messaging
Whether it’s a slogan on a T-shirt or a 15-second video ad, all materials should be cleared before release. Common pitfalls include defamation risks, copyright violations, and omitted disclaimers.
3. Finance and Fundraising
Donor limits, bundling rules, and “dark money” restrictions vary wildly across jurisdictions. Get approval on donor solicitations, receipts, and online forms.
4. Public Outreach
From robocalls to door-to-door petitioning, your field strategy needs legal guardrails. Scripts must avoid deceptive language. SMS outreach has TCPA restrictions. Ignorance here can lead to fines and shutdowns.
5. Post-Campaign Filings
Your job isn’t done after the election. Legal review is critical when filing reports, closing financials, or archiving campaign data.
Key Legal Compliance Areas in Campaigns
Navigating compliance means knowing what to look for. Here are the main categories to watch:
Disclaimers & Disclosures: The rules around “Paid for by” statements differ by state, media, and audience. Digital ads often require clickable disclosures; print mail needs precise font size and placement. Omit this, and your opponent may file a complaint—or worse, the election board may issue a fine.
Messaging Content: Avoid false or unverifiable claims, misleading comparisons, or unauthorized endorsements. Be especially cautious in negative campaigns. Also, never use copyrighted images, logos, or music unless properly licensed.
Finance Compliance: Are you tracking donor limits per cycle? Are you correctly reporting PAC contributions? Errors in campaign finance filings can result in public scandals or financial penalties.
Data Privacy: If you’re collecting voter data, emails, phone numbers, or donations, you must comply with laws like CCPA (California) or GDPR (EU). Make sure your privacy policy is clear, visible, and accurate.
Common Mistakes Without Legal Review
Here are real-world blunders that could have been prevented with legal oversight:
A petition mailer went out in Texas missing a “paid for by” disclaimer and was challenged in court, leading to its disqualification.
A digital ad used copyrighted music and received a takedown notice mid-campaign.
A text campaign lacked opt-out language, resulting in complaints and potential TCPA violations.
A PAC failed to disclose bundled contributions on time and was fined by the FEC.
A candidate falsely claimed an endorsement from a community leader, triggering public backlash and a cease-and-desist letter.
How to Set Up an Effective Legal Review Process
Building a structured, proactive legal review system is the best way to mitigate risk.
Create a Legal Review Checklist: For every campaign element—digital, mail, finance, events—have a list of what must be reviewed and approved.
Define Workflow and Authority: Who reviews what? Establish roles and timelines. Avoid bottlenecks by clarifying when external counsel is needed.
Use Compliance Tools: Project management tools like Notion or Asana can include legal checkpoints. Platforms like ArchiveSocial or Compliancy Group help manage disclosures and data.
Educate Your Team: Hold regular training on campaign laws, and distribute cheat sheets on disclaimers, data privacy, and donor limits.
Working with Legal Counsel: Your Compliance Partner
Legal advisors aren’t just people who tell you “no.” When included early, they help build smarter, risk-aware strategies.
Best practices:
Share drafts early, not after final design.
Batch materials to reduce cost.
Work with attorneys who understand local campaign law.
Keep them informed of changes in strategy or jurisdictions.
Whether you use a retainer or hourly billing, your attorney should be a strategic ally—not a last-minute fixer.
Multi-Jurisdictional Compliance Isn’t Optional
If you’re working across counties or states, one-size-fits-all doesn’t work. For example:
California requires different disclosure wording on mailers than Arizona.
In Colorado, signature gatherers must be registered, while in New Mexico, they don’t.
Some counties restrict canvassing near polling places; others don’t.
Having a legal team or vendor (like Sutton & Smart) that understands localized compliance is a major competitive advantage.
Digital Campaigns Need Legal Oversight Too
The rules are tightening on digital political activity:
Facebook and Google both require advertiser verification and ad disclaimers.
Texting voters? You need opt-out language and TCPA compliance.
Email blasts? CAN-SPAM applies.
AI-generated content? Be cautious—it can blur ethical and legal boundaries.
As the digital space becomes more regulated, legal review must extend to pixels, code, and data—not just print and speech.
Train Your Staff in Legal Literacy
It’s not enough for just leadership to know the rules. Field organizers, designers, volunteers, and vendors should all receive basic legal training.
How to do it:
Onboarding sessions with legal or compliance staff.
1-page cheat sheets for disclaimers and donor language.
Monthly refreshers on any regulatory changes.
Building a “compliance culture” internally prevents accidental violations and empowers your team to do their best work with confidence.
Document Everything: Be Audit-Ready
You should be able to prove:
What was reviewed
When it was reviewed
Who approved it
Keep dated versions of all mailers, scripts, emails, and filings. Use cloud folders with naming conventions and approval stamps.
If you ever face an audit or investigation, organized documentation can protect you and resolve issues quickly.
Conclusion
Legal review and approval isn’t just a formality—it’s the foundation of a credible, effective, and compliant campaign. From disclaimers to donor reporting and digital outreach, every detail matters. By integrating legal oversight into every phase of your campaign or advocacy effort, you reduce risk, build trust, and stay ahead of regulatory challenges. A well-reviewed campaign isn’t slower—it’s smarter, safer, and stronger.
Don’t leave compliance to chance. Whether you’re launching a grassroots petition or a statewide initiative, expert legal guidance can make all the difference.
Ready to safeguard every piece you mail?
Schedule Your Free Political Mail Compliance Audit with Sutton & Smart Now and ensure your next drop is 100% legal, on time, and voter-ready.
Jon Sutton
An expert in management, strategy, and field organizing, Jon has been a frequent commentator in national publications.
Author | Partner
